With heavy quads, cramping calves and the mid-40 degree chill of the November night in their lungs, Cicero-North Syracuse and Baldwinsville appeared destined for a penalty shootout to decide the Class AAA girls soccer championship after over 100 minutes of deadlock.
That is, until Northstar sophomore defender Margaret Dufort danced down the wing, drawing a penalty kick with just over five minutes remaining in double overtime.
Senior captain Emery Kozdemba stepped up to the spot, calmly sent Baldwinsville goalkeeper Abagail DeSimone to the left and slotted the ball into the bottom right corner to break Bees' hearts and hand CNS its fourth straight Class AAA sectional crown, 2-1.
Complete Box Score »
"I knew where I was going to go," Kozdemba said. "I go to the same spot and I knew I had to make it. I knew I had to do it to finish the game."
Baldwinsville head coach Kathy Morse felt the contest should have gone to penalty kicks.
"I think that the game should have continued on," Morse said. "I think it's a tough call to make with five minutes to go."
With its win over Baldwinsville (10-6-1), CNS (16-1) sealed a second consecutive season without a loss to a Section III opponent. Baldwinsville's 2-0 win over the Northstars in October 2024 is the last time a local team has defeated CNS.
Since the Class AAA tournament was introduced in 2023, the Northstars are a perfect 9-0 in sectional play, including a pair of one-goal championship game wins over the Bees.
"They're very good off the ball, running off the ball and their passing is really good and they're fast," Morse said. "So we had a game plan; I thought we played well. I think our game plan slowed them down and helped us, but they found a way to win."
Led by sophomore star forward Sloane Raymond, CNS mercilessly pressured Baldwinsville's goal all game. DeSimone made several great plays in net, in addition to three instances where she sprinted out of her goal to snuff out breakaway chances with goal-saving tackles.
Despite CNS owning the bulk of the possession and the scoring chances, Baldwinsville found the goal first. With less than a minute remaining in the first half, Gianna McDermott pounced on a loose ball off a Naomi Locke corner and poked the ball into the back of the net to stun CNS and give Baldwinsville a 1-0 advantage.
When the two teams came out after halftime, Baldwinsville's players had already been on the field for a couple minutes before CNS finally broke its sideline huddle.
"We were definitely a little bit down after that," Raymond said. "But we knew we had a whole half left to just bring our energy back up and win the game."
CNS pushed even harder in the second half and played almost entirely on Baldwinsville's side of the field before Raymond finally broke through for the game-tying goal in the 55th minute off a Kozdemba assist.
Neither team seriously threatened for the rest of regulation and the match headed to overtime.
DeSimone made another collection of impressive plays in the extra session, tipping a Raymond shot over the bar in the 81st minute, stopping a Raymond breakaway with a slide tackle in the 91st and catching another Northstar rocket in the 94th.
"She played really well today," Morse said. "We knew she could, she stepped up today big-time."
Neither team had much for chances in the first 10 minutes of the second overtime, though Baldwinsville had its best sustained spell of possession and attacking chances since the first half.
All of a sudden, with one errant tackle and one perfectly-placed spot kick, it was over.
"I think it was definitely coming," Kozdemba said. "I told (my teammates) the whole time, I was like 'It's coming, it's coming guys,' and it finally did."
Next up, CNS faces Section II champion Shenendehowa in the regional round at 2:30 p.m. Saturday at Niskayuna High School. Back on Oct. 3, Shenendehowa traveled to Cicero and won 4-0, CNS' only loss of the season and its worst defeat in almost three years.
Kozdemba, Raymond and Lenchert all acknowledged the Northstars did not play their best on that Saturday morning.
"Honestly, we didn't come out ready to play that day," Lenchert said. "Really, it's our only blemish of the year."
"One thing we always say is 'Press, press their back line,'" Kozdemba said. "And we didn't do that that game."
Shenendehowa also eliminated CNS in the regional round in 2023, the year that kicked off CNS' run of four straight state tournament trips.
In that 2-1 loss, then-eighth grader Abigail Mackey notched the only Northstars goal of the day to cap her first career varsity season. Now, she's a junior, the team's second-leading scorer and a two-time First-Team All-CNY selection.
After falling short in their first-ever state title game last season but returning all 11 of their starters, the Northstars are hoping to take home their first trophy this time around.
They'll have to get past Shenendehowa first. In the latest NYSSWA state rankings, Shenendehowa is No. 2 and CNS is No. 3.
"Win states. That's why we're doing it," Lenchert said. "We went into the season with the same thing we did when we went in last season. We went in with the goal of winning states, and this is another step along the line."